Big Cartel vs Loop Returns Pricing (2026)

Price is one row. To weigh the features too, use our feature comparison template →

Which one is cheaper?

Big Cartel starts lower at $15/mo, compared to $155/mo for Loop Returns.

Can I use either one for free?

Both offer free plans, so you can try each without paying. Start with whichever fits your workflow better and upgrade when you hit the limits.

How do they charge?

Both use a flat-rate model, so the comparison is straightforward — it comes down to features and limits at each price point.

Which one is a better deal?

Depends on what you need. Big Cartel: This is budget territory compared to Shopify or BigCommerce — Big Cartel is explicitly courting indie artists and small-batch makers who'd bounce off a $39+/mo Shopify plan. They're not trying to win enterprise or even serious mid-size retail; they're the low-commitment option for someone testing if their craft can be a business. Loop Returns: Sitting in the low-to-mid range for dedicated returns management platforms, Loop isn't trying to compete on rock-bottom price — the free Checkout+ tier is a land grab, but real usage starts at $155/mo and climbs fast to $340/mo before you even factor in Order Tracking. They're clearly chasing mid-market Shopify brands that have outgrown native return processes but aren't yet enterprise-scale, positioning against pricier all-in-one platforms while undercutting custom-built solutions.

Still deciding? See the best Big Cartel alternatives or the best Loop Returns alternatives, ranked with verified pricing.