Best Big Cartel Alternatives (2026)

Big Cartel alternatives at a glance

1. 1

   AfterShip

   E-commerce

   Post-purchase experience platform.

   AfterShip sits in the mid-market range for post-purchase tracking tools — not the cheapest (plenty of Shopify apps undercut them), but not enterprise-priced either. They're going after scaling DTC brands and mid-size retailers who've outgrown basic carrier emails but aren't ready to build custom tracking infrastructure.

   Plans: Essentials $29/mo · Premium $59/mo · Enterprise Contact Sales

   From $29/mo · Big Cartel vs AfterShip → AfterShip pricing →
2. 2

   BigCommerce

   E-commerce

   Enterprise ecommerce platform.

   Positioned as the premium enterprise alternative to Shopify, with that $399 Scale tier sitting well above most mid-market competitors. They're clearly going after serious merchants who've outgrown basic platforms and need robust B2B features.

   Plans: Core $39/mo · Growth $105/mo · Scale $399/mo · Performance Contact Sales

   From $39/mo Free trial · Big Cartel vs BigCommerce → BigCommerce pricing →
3. 3

   EasyPost

   E-commerce

   Shipping API for developers.

   They're positioned as the developer-friendly middle ground — cheaper and more API-first than Shippo's higher tiers, but not trying to undercut on raw label cost like Pirateship. The real target is mid-market e-commerce and logistics teams who need programmable shipping infrastructure, not a UI-first tool.

   Plans: Free Access (Wallet Carriers) $0/mo · Bring Your Own Carrier Accounts (BYOCA) $20/mo · Enterprise Plan Contact Sales · EasyPost Tracking API Contact Sales · EasyPost Advanced Tracking Contact Sales · EasyPost Insurance and Claims API Contact Sales

   From $20/mo Free plan · Big Cartel vs EasyPost → EasyPost pricing →
4. 4

   Easyship

   E-commerce

   Shipping platform with discounted rates across 550+ courier services.

   Easyship sits in the mid-market lane — pricier than bare-bones shipping calculators but cheaper than enterprise logistics platforms like ShipStation's higher tiers. They're chasing DTC brands and small-to-mid ecommerce sellers who've outgrown manual shipping but aren't ready for a full 3PL relationship.

   Plans: Free $0/mo · Plus $29/mo · Premier $69/mo · Scale $99/mo

   From $29/mo Free plan Free trial · Big Cartel vs Easyship → Easyship pricing →
5. 5

   Ecwid

   E-commerce

   Add a store to any website.

   Ecwid is firmly in the budget-to-mid-market camp — undercutting Shopify's comparable tiers while positioning against BigCommerce and Wix eCommerce for cost-conscious small businesses. The nonprofit discount signals they're also chasing mission-driven orgs that Shopify largely ignores at this price point.

   Plans: Starter $5/mo · Venture $35/mo · Business $65/mo · Unlimited $149/mo

   From $5/mo · Big Cartel vs Ecwid → Ecwid pricing →
6. 6

   Gelato

   E-commerce

   Global print-on-demand network.

   They're positioning against Printful and Printify by making the entry point genuinely free with no monthly commitment, then competing on margin recovery through discounts rather than undercutting base product prices. It's a mid-market play — not the cheapest per-unit option, but the subscription discount structure targets serious sellers who want predictable cost reduction without going enterprise.

   Plans: Free $0/mo · Gelato+ Contact Sales · Gelato Platinum Contact Sales

   Custom pricing Free plan · Big Cartel vs Gelato → Gelato pricing →
7. 7

   Gumroad

   E-commerce

   Sell digital products and memberships.

   Plans: Gumroad $0/mo

   Custom pricing Free plan · Big Cartel vs Gumroad → Gumroad pricing →
8. 8

   Judge.me

   E-commerce

   Product reviews that convert.

   They're the aggressive low-cost option in the Shopify reviews space, undercutting competitors like Yotpo and Okendo by a wide margin. The $15 ceiling is a direct pitch to mid-market Shopify merchants who are tired of review apps that scale fees alongside their success.

   Plans: Free $0/mo · Awesome $15/mo

   From $15/mo Free plan · Big Cartel vs Judge.me → Judge.me pricing →
9. 9

   Kajabi

   E-commerce

   All-in-one knowledge commerce.

   Kajabi plays the premium all-in-one card against Teachable and Thinkific — they're not trying to win on price, they're selling the 'one platform to replace five tools' story. The 50% spring promo is a tell that they're feeling pressure from cheaper competitors and need to lower the entry barrier without permanently cutting rates.

   Plans: Starter Contact Sales · Basic Contact Sales · Growth Contact Sales · Pro Contact Sales

   Custom pricing Free trial · Big Cartel vs Kajabi → Kajabi pricing →
10. 10

    LearnWorlds

    E-commerce

    White-label course platform.

    LearnWorlds sits in the mid-to-premium range for course platforms — more expensive than Teachable's entry tiers but competitive with Thinkific and Kajabi for serious course creators. They're clearly going after professional educators and training businesses, not hobbyists or first-time creators.

    Plans: STARTER $29/mo · PRO TRAINER $99/mo · LEARNING CENTER $299/mo · CORPORATE Contact Sales

    From $29/mo Free trial · Big Cartel vs LearnWorlds → LearnWorlds pricing →

None of these fit? Browse the full pricing directory →

What is the best alternative to Big Cartel?

AfterShip is the closest Big Cartel alternative we track for e-commerce. Paid plans start at $29/mo. BigCommerce and EasyPost are also worth a look.

Are there free alternatives to Big Cartel?

Yes — EasyPost, Easyship, Gelato and 2 more offer a free plan, so you can switch without paying up front.

How much do Big Cartel alternatives cost?

Entry prices range from $5/mo (Ecwid) to $39/mo (BigCommerce). Each product page has the full verified tier breakdown.

Is there a cheaper alternative to Big Cartel?

Yes — Big Cartel starts at $15/mo, while Ecwid ($5/mo) starts lower.