Bonusly vs SurePayroll Pricing (2026)
How do these two stack up on price? Here's what each one costs, what you get, and where the value sits.
| Bonusly | SurePayroll | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts at | $5/mo | $29/mo |
| Number of plans | 3 | 2 |
| Free plan | — | |
| Free trial | — | |
| Pricing model | per-seat | hybrid |
Free
- Up to 8 users
- Peer recognition and guidance
- Slack and Teams integrations
- iOS and Android apps
Team + Bizy AI
Popular- Unlimited seats
- Advanced pulse check analytics
- Automated milestone celebrations
- HRIS integrations and provisioning
- 24/7 chat support
- Enhanced 1:1s with smart agendas
- Unlimited performance recaps
- Automated manager alerts
Organization + Bizy AI
- Company announcements
- Awards and Incentives
- Company-wide analytics and insights
- Recognition quality reporting
- SAML SSO Integrations
- Dedicated CSM
- Training library
- Onboarding assistance
Small Business
- Unlimited payroll runs
- Live phone and chat support
- Payroll taxes calculated
- W-2 & 1099 form filing available
- Federal & state payroll taxes filed & deposited
- FREE onboarding with help from real humans
- Free 2-day direct deposit
- Schedule payroll to run automatically
- Multiple pay rates & bonuses
- New hire reporting
- Online pay stubs
- Mobile app for employers and employees
Nanny & Household Payroll
- State tax ID registration assistance
- Run payroll from your phone
- Includes one employee
- Schedule payroll to run automatically
- Federal and state taxes filed and deposited automatically
- Unlimited payroll runs and free 2-day direct deposit
- Signature-ready Schedule H
- Free onboarding assistance
- Supports W-2 employees & 1099 contractors
Bonusly vs SurePayroll FAQ
- Which one is cheaper?
- Bonusly starts lower at $5/mo, compared to $29/mo for SurePayroll.
- Can I use either one for free?
- Bonusly has a free plan. SurePayroll doesn't — you'll need to pay from day one.
- How do they charge?
- Different approach here. Bonusly uses per-seat pricing, while SurePayroll goes with hybrid. That changes the math depending on your team size and usage.
- Which one is a better deal?
- Depends on what you need. Bonusly: At $3–$5/seat/month, Bonusly sits in the affordable-to-mid range for employee recognition platforms — cheaper than Workhuman or Achievers, roughly competitive with Nectar. They're clearly targeting mid-market teams that want something more structured than a Slack shoutout channel but aren't ready to commit to an enterprise recognition suite. SurePayroll: SurePayroll undercuts Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll on the base rate, positioning itself as the budget-friendly pick for tiny businesses and households that don't need a full HR suite. It's chasing price-sensitive micro-businesses and nanny employers who'd otherwise overpay for enterprise-grade payroll tools they'll never use.
Still deciding? See the best Bonusly alternatives or the best SurePayroll alternatives, ranked with verified pricing.
Keep tabs on both.
We'll monitor pricing changes for Bonusly and SurePayroll and let you know when something moves.