Recurly vs Square Pricing (2026)
How do these two stack up on price? Here's what each one costs, what you get, and where the value sits.
Starter
- Automated global subscription billing
- Flexible plans and pricing
- Static churn-prevention tools
- 1 Dunning campaign
- 10+ payment methods
- 20+ payment gateways
All-Access
Popular- AI-Powered agents, analytics, insights
- Intelligent churn-prevention tools
- Multiple dunning campaigns
- Advanced plans, pricing, promotions
- Payments orchestration across multiple gateways
- Custom reporting, additional analytics, and automated exports
- Additional payment methods including ACH, gateways, and communications languages
- Multicurrency
- Single sign-on
- And more!
All-Access for Shopify
- Intelligent churn-prevention tools
- Customized bundles
- Subscribe and save
- Prepaid and gift subscriptions
- Hybrid subscription support
- Cancel-save flows and surveys
- Self-serve bulk updater
- Analytics and integrations
- Hosted subscriber portal with passwordless login
- And more!
Engage
- AI powered propensity to churn model
- 1-click billing integration
- Personalized offers
- Cancel save, upsell, cross sell capabilities
- AB testing
- Granular segmentation
- Low code prompt builder
- Advanced analytics
- Robust integrations
RevRec
- Automated contract modifications
- SSP automation
- Rules-driven allocations
- Real-time revenue insights & forecasting
- Automated monthly close
- Unified workbench
- Multi-GAAP compliance
- Immutable audit trail
- Multi-everything support
Square Free
- POS app for any payment
- Online site
- Item library
- Invoicing
- Booking
- Checking and savings accounts
Square Plus
Popular- POS features for every industry
- Lower processing fees
- Loyalty rewards program
- Email and text message marketing
- Staff management
Square Premium
- 24/7 priority support
- Advanced reporting
- Lowest processing fees
- More text message marketing
- No gift card load fees
Square Pro
Recurly vs Square FAQ
- Which one is cheaper?
- Square is the cheaper option, starting at $49/mo vs $249/mo for Recurly.
- Can I use either one for free?
- Square has a free plan. Recurly doesn't — though they do offer a free trial.
- How do they charge?
- Different approach here. Recurly uses usage-based pricing, while Square goes with flat-rate. That changes the math depending on your team size and usage.
- Which one is a better deal?
- Depends on what you need. Recurly: At sub-1% of billing volume, Recurly is pitching itself as cheaper than Stripe Billing's percentage-based fees at scale, targeting mid-market SaaS and subscription commerce companies that have outgrown basic payment tools but aren't ready for a full Zuora implementation. They're the pragmatic middle ground — not the cheapest, not the most enterprise. Square: Square sits in the accessible middle — not as cheap as Stripe for pure online processing, not as enterprise-heavy as Adyen or Worldpay. They're clearly targeting SMBs and brick-and-mortar businesses who want an all-in-one POS ecosystem without a complex contract.
Still deciding? See the best Recurly alternatives or the best Square alternatives, ranked with verified pricing.
Keep tabs on both.
We'll monitor pricing changes for Recurly and Square and let you know when something moves.