AfterShip vs Sellfy Pricing (2026)
How do these two stack up on price? Here's what each one costs, what you get, and where the value sits.
Essentials
- Branded tracking page with your logo & colors
- Automatic carrier detection and correction
- Email & SMS notifications for every shipment milestone
- Tracking dashboard with status & reports
Premium
- Fully customizable tracking page + custom domain
- AI-powered EDD & product recommendations
- Full analytics suite
- API & webhooks
- Order Edits
Enterprise
- Dedicated CSM & onboarding
- Enterprise SLAs & SSO
- Custom integrations
- Multi-org management
Starter
Popular- Up to $10k in sales per year
- Sell downloads, subscriptions and merch
- Unlimited products
- Email marketing
- Core marketing features
- Transaction fees
- Digital products
- Physical product
- Subscriptions
- Print-on-demand products
- Maximum product file size
- Custom fields
- Product migration
- Store editor
- Store themes
- Apply custom code
- Connect your own domain
- Remove "Sellfy" branding
- Store design migration
- Coupon codes
- Customer reviews
- Free Email marketing credits
- Product upselling
- Cart abandonment
- Affiliate program
- PayPal/Stripe gateway support
- Free SSL certificate
- Optimized for mobile devices
- Advanced VAT & tax settings
- Integrations
- 24/7 email support
- Priority support
Business
- Up to $50k in sales per year
- Sell downloads, subscriptions and merch
- Unlimited products
- Email marketing
- Custom fields
- Core marketing features
- Product upselling
- Cart abandonment
- Affiliate marketing
- Transaction fees
- Digital products
- Physical product
- Subscriptions
- Print-on-demand products
- Maximum product file size
- Product migration
- Store editor
- Store themes
- Apply custom code
- Connect your own domain
- Remove "Sellfy" branding
- Store design migration
- Coupon codes
- Customer reviews
- Free Email marketing credits
- Cart abandonment
- Affiliate program
- PayPal/Stripe gateway support
- Free SSL certificate
- Optimized for mobile devices
- Advanced VAT & tax settings
- Integrations
- 24/7 email support
- Priority support
Premium
- Up to $200k in sales per year
- Sell downloads, subscriptions and merch
- Unlimited products
- Email marketing
- Custom fields
- Core marketing features
- Product upselling
- Cart abandonment
- Affiliate marketing
- Product and design migration
- Priority support
- Transaction fees
- Digital products
- Physical product
- Subscriptions
- Print-on-demand products
- Maximum product file size
- Product migration
- Store editor
- Store themes
- Apply custom code
- Connect your own domain
- Remove "Sellfy" branding
- Store design migration
- Coupon codes
- Customer reviews
- Free Email marketing credits
- Affiliate program
- PayPal/Stripe gateway support
- Free SSL certificate
- Optimized for mobile devices
- Advanced VAT & tax settings
- Integrations
- 24/7 email support
AfterShip vs Sellfy FAQ
- Which one is cheaper?
- AfterShip starts lower at $29/mo, compared to $39/mo for Sellfy.
- Can I use either one for free?
- Neither has a free plan. But Sellfy offers a free trial.
- How do they charge?
- Different approach here. AfterShip uses usage-based pricing, while Sellfy goes with flat-rate. That changes the math depending on your team size and usage.
- Which one is a better deal?
- Depends on what you need. AfterShip: AfterShip sits in the mid-market range for post-purchase tracking tools — not the cheapest (plenty of Shopify apps undercut them), but not enterprise-priced either. They're going after scaling DTC brands and mid-size retailers who've outgrown basic carrier emails but aren't ready to build custom tracking infrastructure. Sellfy: Sellfy sits in the mid-market of digital commerce platforms — cheaper than Shopify with apps stacked on, but pricier than bare-bones options like Gumroad's free tier. They're clearly targeting creators and small digital businesses who want an all-in-one storefront without stitching together tools, and the annual discount to $29/mo makes Starter competitive for that audience.
Keep tabs on both.
We'll monitor pricing changes for AfterShip and Sellfy and let you know when something moves.