Big Cartel vs Sellfy Pricing (2026)
How do these two stack up on price? Here's what each one costs, what you get, and where the value sits.
| Big Cartel | Sellfy | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts at | $15/mo | $39/mo |
| Number of plans | 2 | 3 |
| Free plan | — | |
| Free trial | ||
| Pricing model | flat-rate | flat-rate |
Platinum
Popular- Support for custom domains
- Sell physical and digital products
- Print shipping labels and track orders
- Customize your shop design
- Easy-install apps for print-on-demand & more
Diamond
- Recover abandoned carts
- Schedule product drops
- Password-protect products
- Connect to 7,000+ apps with Zapier
- Priority support from humans
Starter
Popular- Up to $10k in sales per year
- Sell downloads, subscriptions and merch
- Unlimited products
- Email marketing
- Core marketing features
Business
- Up to $50k in sales per year
- Sell downloads, subscriptions and merch
- Unlimited products
- Email marketing
- Custom fields
- Core marketing features
- Product upselling
- Cart abandonment
- Affiliate marketing
- Remove "Sellfy" branding
- Store design migration
Premium
- Up to $200k in sales per year
- Sell downloads, subscriptions and merch
- Unlimited products
- Email marketing
- Custom fields
- Core marketing features
- Product upselling
- Cart abandonment
- Affiliate marketing
- Product and design migration
- Priority support
Big Cartel vs Sellfy FAQ
- Which one is cheaper?
- Big Cartel starts lower at $15/mo, compared to $39/mo for Sellfy.
- Can I use either one for free?
- Big Cartel has a free plan. Sellfy doesn't — though they do offer a free trial.
- How do they charge?
- Both use a flat-rate model, so the comparison is straightforward — it comes down to features and limits at each price point.
- Which one is a better deal?
- Depends on what you need. Big Cartel: This is budget territory compared to Shopify or BigCommerce — Big Cartel is explicitly courting indie artists and small-batch makers who'd bounce off a $39+/mo Shopify plan. They're not trying to win enterprise or even serious mid-size retail; they're the low-commitment option for someone testing if their craft can be a business. Sellfy: Sellfy sits mid-market — pricier than bare-bones tools like Payhip or Gumroad's free-to-start model, but cheaper than full-blown ecommerce platforms like Shopify once you factor in app costs. They're courting creators and small merchants who want an all-in-one shop without assembling a stack of plugins.
Still deciding? See the best Big Cartel alternatives or the best Sellfy alternatives, ranked with verified pricing.
Keep tabs on both.
We'll monitor pricing changes for Big Cartel and Sellfy and let you know when something moves. See how competitor pricing monitoring works.