SurePayroll vs 15Five Pricing (2026)
How do these two stack up on price? Here's what each one costs, what you get, and where the value sits.
| SurePayroll | 15Five | |
|---|---|---|
| Starts at | $29/mo | $4/mo |
| Number of plans | 2 | 3 |
| Free plan | — | — |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Pricing model | hybrid | per-seat |
Small Business
- Unlimited payroll runs
- Live phone and chat support
- Payroll taxes calculated
- W-2 & 1099 form filing available
- Federal & state payroll taxes filed & deposited
- FREE onboarding with help from real humans
- Free 2-day direct deposit
- Schedule payroll to run automatically
- Multiple pay rates & bonuses
- New hire reporting
- Online pay stubs
- Mobile app for employers and employees
Nanny & Household Payroll
- State tax ID registration assistance
- Run payroll from your phone
- Includes one employee
- Schedule payroll to run automatically
- Federal and state taxes filed and deposited automatically
- Unlimited payroll runs and free 2-day direct deposit
- Signature-ready Schedule H
- Free onboarding assistance
- Supports W-2 employees & 1099 contractors
Engage
- Employee Engagement Surveys
- Targeted Assessments
- Action Planning
- Heat Maps & Data Breakdowns
- Benchmarking
Perform
- AMAYA
- Insights Dashboard
- AI-Assisted Performance Reviews
- 15Five Agents
- OKRs & Goals
- 360° Feedback
- Talent Matrix
- Career Paths & Plans
Total Platform
Popular- Manager Training Microlearnings
SurePayroll vs 15Five FAQ
- Which one is cheaper?
- 15Five is the cheaper option, starting at $4/mo vs $29/mo for SurePayroll.
- Can I use either one for free?
- Neither has a free plan.
- How do they charge?
- Different approach here. SurePayroll uses hybrid pricing, while 15Five goes with per-seat. That changes the math depending on your team size and usage.
- Which one is a better deal?
- Depends on what you need. SurePayroll: SurePayroll undercuts Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll on the base rate, positioning itself as the budget-friendly pick for tiny businesses and households that don't need a full HR suite. It's chasing price-sensitive micro-businesses and nanny employers who'd otherwise overpay for enterprise-grade payroll tools they'll never use. 15Five: They're mid-market priced — not trying to undercut Lattice or Culture Amp, but not charging enterprise rates either. At $16 all-in, they're competitive against Lattice's ~$11–17 range and positioned as a more integrated alternative to buying separate engagement and performance tools from different vendors.
Keep tabs on both.
We'll monitor pricing changes for SurePayroll and 15Five and let you know when something moves.